...it's interesting to see how Wikipedia is being used or not being used by Information Professionals in the Legal Community and how there is some mistrust of Wikipedia but also some good examples of people using Wikipedia to provide overviews of topics or as a place for finding additional resources.
In the US the discussion over Wikipedia as a source for information has been going on for much longer and the following just provide a taster of what people are talking about:
- Just say no to Wikipedia are you crazy?
- Citing Wikipedia - Just say no
- Wikipedia - Useful information or unreliable source?
- Wikipedia clamps down on unreliable editors
So what do BIALL members think, Wikipedia useful source if used critically and carefully or disaster waiting to happen?
If used like any other resource – checking the sources it is refrenced from etc – it is a great tool. I am often surprised at just how accurate it is on topics that I am familiar with. Would never use it as a sole source for information on something though.
If used like any other resource – checking the sources it is refrenced from etc – it is a great tool. I am often surprised at just how accurate it is on topics that I am familiar with. Would never use it as a sole source for information on something though.
It depends on the context – for anything other than idle curiosity the risk seems to be fairly high, unless you verify with another source (in which case why not use that source instead?) You pay nothing to access wikipedia and the contributors do it for free so it’s essentially a gift-horse (might win the Derby but might equally turn out to be a mule…) I agree with Scott that it’s surprising how often it is a winner.
It depends on the context – for anything other than idle curiosity the risk seems to be fairly high, unless you verify with another source (in which case why not use that source instead?) You pay nothing to access wikipedia and the contributors do it for free so it’s essentially a gift-horse (might win the Derby but might equally turn out to be a mule…) I agree with Scott that it’s surprising how often it is a winner.
I presume people have seen the article on the front page of the Law Society Gazette (12th June issue)? ‘Net surfing lawyers warned of compliance risk’. Its probably on their website by now.
If you need some ammunition to scare the trainees – and everyone lese for that matter – this might be it.
I presume people have seen the article on the front page of the Law Society Gazette (12th June issue)? ‘Net surfing lawyers warned of compliance risk’. Its probably on their website by now.
If you need some ammunition to scare the trainees – and everyone lese for that matter – this might be it.