Author Bio: Allison Harrison, is a writer who currently works freelance for Kilcoyne & Company Solicitors, who specialise in criminal law and defending complex crimes and high profile cases for many years.
However, there have been some fairly unusual defence tactics used in criminal cases in recent history. We’re going to outline three of these tactics below. As you’ll see, these brazen claims of innocence are often attached to high-profile (read: wealthy) defendants. 1. The defendant’s unreliability
This comes up more often in civil suits than in outright criminal cases; however, it still sheds light on an increasingly popular defence tactic. There have been a few prominent examples of this in the US lately, the most famous of which involves de-famed cyclist, Lance Armstrong. Winner of seven Tour de France titles (all of which have since been revoked), Armstrong was sued by his former sponsor, the US Postal Service.
After repeated denials, Armstrong later admitted to doping during his cycling career. The Postal Service’s suit (which was technically filed by a private citizen on the Postal Service’s behalf) claims that Armstrong deceived taxpayers when he accepted sponsorship from a government agency. His defence was quite simple and amounts to saying, “It was obvious that I really was doping, so you never should have believed me when I said I wasn’t.”
Apparently, if you are a bad enough liar, the false claims that you make cannot be held against you—at least in the opinion of some defence attorneys.
2. Gay Panic
This line of defence is rarely effective, but that doesn’t stop defendants from trying it out. It usually comes into play when the defendant is accused of assault or rape, and the victim is a homosexual.
Specifically, the defendant (who is straight) will claim that the victim made some sort of homosexual advances on them. This was so shocking, that it induced a form of hysteria or psychosis—i.e., gay panic. This state of mind is temporary but amounts to a form of insanity. In other words, the defendant wasn’t in a sound state of mind at the time of the crime.
As mentioned, this tactic rarely succeeds. Typically it is used to offset the spectre of hate crime allegations. In this sense, the gay panic defence may be deemed successful, in as much as it could be used to persuade juries or judges that the accused acted out of hysteria rather than cool, calculated hatred.
3. Too many emails
In a case that has received plenty of press, hedge fund SAC Capital Advisors has been sued for failing to catch two of their portfolio managers who are currently embroiled in an insider trading scandal. In particular, the suit is aimed at founder Steve Cohen, who the prosecution states should have known what sort of shady business his underlings were getting up to.
This case draws its main thrust from Cohen’s email records. The prosecution states that the founder received plenty of suspicious information via email that would have sent up red flags for any reasonable person. In other words, Cohen knew what was going on and chose to do nothing about it.
In his defence, the billionaire’s attorneys state that the hedge fund founder simply receives too many emails to really read them all. They even attached a figure to this line of defence: 11 percent. That’s how many of his emails he usually reads. So, while it’s true that he did receive incriminating emails, his defence team believes his negligence in reading them should get him off the hook.
Many thanks to Allison Harrison, for her contribution.
0 Comments