For me the great thing about the BIALL conference is all the mini conversations you have in between the sessions and during the social events, finding out little snippets of information, meeting new people and catching up with people you already know.
I came back inspired to make more use of Web 2.0 tools (Phil Bradley's talk) - although the advice that you shouldn't listen to technical people is a mite controversial, and being bit of a techie myself I couldn't possibly agree! But I loved the bit about empowering librarians, and that technical people are there to serve their organisations, including their libraries. How many times have I seen decisions taken about library software made by the Head of IT when it is the library's tool? The IT role is to ensure that the software works within the IT environment and that it will integrate, but at the end of the day the library staff are the experts when it comes choosing their tools. Collaboration is the answer.
But going back to Web 2.0, there are some excellent tools there, but they need to be used judiciously and not just because they are there . The question should be "Is this adding value, or is it just a gimmick because it's possible?"
The publishers' forum was interesting, but I was promised fireworks and it didn't really happen. I thought the debate about federated searching could have gone a bit further. When you talk to lawyers about searching several resources at once their eyes positively light up. There seems some reluctance on the part of some vendors to allow by-passing of the search tools and functionality they provide, but if the lawyer doesn't know where to start then they are not going to using it in the first place or they would be faced with repeating the search several times. Federated searching should be a compliment to, not a replacement for, vendor's tools.
BIALL Conference 2026 – Call for Papers
The BIALL Conference Committee is delighted to open the Call for Papers for the 56th Annual Conference and Exhibition...
I quite agree about the issue of federated searching. There is a real desire within our firm to have the facility to search a number of databases at the same time. I completely agree that it would be a tool to complement, for complicated search strategies users would turn to the native search functionality of an individual database.
One of the federated search engine providers is hosting a round table discussion on this very issue this week in London – maybe we’ll see the fireworks there!
I quite agree about the issue of federated searching. There is a real desire within our firm to have the facility to search a number of databases at the same time. I completely agree that it would be a tool to complement, for complicated search strategies users would turn to the native search functionality of an individual database.
One of the federated search engine providers is hosting a round table discussion on this very issue this week in London – maybe we’ll see the fireworks there!
I’m glad that you liked my talk; thanks for your kind words. And yes, it did get quite controversial now and then, but that’s what makes it fun. And I do actually like tecchies, despite appearances! 🙂
I’m glad that you liked my talk; thanks for your kind words. And yes, it did get quite controversial now and then, but that’s what makes it fun. And I do actually like tecchies, despite appearances! 🙂
Penny thanks for your post. I like John agree with your comments about federated searching. There is definitely a desire amongst law firms to have the ability to search multiple databases at once or integrate publisher content within intranets (although apparently these are on the way out), portals and Know How Management systems.
As you both say these should be tools to complement rather then be relied on. Having said that I think we need to be aware of the concerns publishers have that is that they spend a huge amount of time creating content and building databses that are intuitive only for a third party to whack a search engine on it that doesn’t necessarily provide a good solution.
Penny thanks for your post. I like John agree with your comments about federated searching. There is definitely a desire amongst law firms to have the ability to search multiple databases at once or integrate publisher content within intranets (although apparently these are on the way out), portals and Know How Management systems.
As you both say these should be tools to complement rather then be relied on. Having said that I think we need to be aware of the concerns publishers have that is that they spend a huge amount of time creating content and building databses that are intuitive only for a third party to whack a search engine on it that doesn’t necessarily provide a good solution.
I can completely understand publishers concerns about the quality of results coming back via a third party search engine as we’ve looked at some that have brought back frankly bizarre results.
I would always turn to the original resource for any in depth research rather than use a third party search engine. However, for a solicitor who just wants to see what articles or commentary are available on a certain case or piece of legislation then having the facility to search multiple sources at once would be a real boon.
I think over the past few years publishers have made great efforts (and should be applauded) to allow us to interact with their content in different ways, such as deep linking, building links, ip authentication and RSS feeds. Perhaps integrating with external search engine providers is the next step?
I can completely understand publishers concerns about the quality of results coming back via a third party search engine as we’ve looked at some that have brought back frankly bizarre results.
I would always turn to the original resource for any in depth research rather than use a third party search engine. However, for a solicitor who just wants to see what articles or commentary are available on a certain case or piece of legislation then having the facility to search multiple sources at once would be a real boon.
I think over the past few years publishers have made great efforts (and should be applauded) to allow us to interact with their content in different ways, such as deep linking, building links, ip authentication and RSS feeds. Perhaps integrating with external search engine providers is the next step?