Do lawyers need to be scholars?

Written by @admin

8th November 2011

By: Natasha Choolhun

11 October 2011 - Sponsored by LexisNexis

This was an engaging debate touching on legal education, the legal market and the duty of the profession to support all parties, students, lawyers and consumers. Below are the key points made by the panel to illustrate how the debate evolved.

Speaker 1: Prof. Philippe Sands QC (UCL Faculty of Laws/ Matrix Chambers)
Philippe wished he hadn’t studied law as an undergraduate as law degrees “close the mind”. Lawyers need critical thinking skills which law degrees do not foster. He thinks current legal education is too employability driven, which is “a bad thing.”

The questions we should be asking are, “what is the social function of a lawyer?” and “how many lawyers do we need?”

Speaker 2: Rebecca Huxley-Binns (Law teacher of the year 2010, Nottingham Trent)
Rebecca proposed that law degrees should be “value driven” and suggested scrapping the 7 foundation subjects and introducing skills and ethics. However, students do want to know how to be employable.

Speaker 3: David Bickerton (managing partner, Clifford Chance)
CC are happy with the quality of trainees they receive, (it doesn’t appear there are problems with legal education to them).

Speaker 4: Prof. Richard Moorhead (Cardiff Law School)
Richard concluded that lawyers do not need to be scholars as much work is transactional/ routine, but lawyers do need scholars to write textbooks & teach.

Speaker 5: Prof. Stephen Mayson (Director of Legal Services Policy Institute, College of Law)
Stephen delivered the most controversial statement of the debate, that the current legal education on offer is “not fit for purpose”. He said the basic skills needed to underpin a new model are research, writing and reasoning. Market developments should also be taken into consideration e.g. how does legal process outsourcing & “Co-op” law affect job supply for law students?

You May Also Like...

0 Comments