BIALL on Law and Order: Trends in Legal Information Provision

Written by @admin

4th July 2007

On Behalf of Barbara Tearle and PR Committee:

BIALL on Law and Order: Trends in Legal Information Provision

BIALL's PR and Promotions Committee is looking at the possibility of repeating a BIALL survey that was carried out ten years ago and published in 1999 under the title Law and Order. Its aim was to investigate the management and provision of legal information, specifically examining the impact of technology on working practices. Sweet & Maxwell funded the survey to coincide with their 200th anniversary.

The committee would like your views on -
a) whether the survey should be repeated
b) how frequently, eg annually (oh, no, not another survey!), every 2, 5 or 10 years (good for comparative purposes) and MOST important
c) what issues you would like to see covered

To help with the last question, the conclusions of the 1999 report are on the BIALL website http://www.biall.org.uk/Home.asp?id=i101&h999
The original survey and report was a snapshot of practices 10 years ago and much has changed in the intervening period. Providing and managing electronic information remains at the centre of the provision of legal information services. It is also central to the business of publishers and the committee expects that they would benefit from the report as much as legal information professionals.

The committee is also looking for a sponsor for the survey ... offers welcome!

You May Also Like...

12 Comments

  1. Margie Jones

    The survey is valuable and realistically I expect how often it is repeated will depend upon funding. The introduction of the internet and online information has had, and is having, a huge impact on information management. I have just read an article in CILIP’s lates Update on Out Sourcing (Library & Information Update July/August 2007 Vol 6 p 4)and maybe this is something the survey should consider covering too?

    Margaret Jones
    Lester Aldridge LLP

  2. Margie Jones

    The survey is valuable and realistically I expect how often it is repeated will depend upon funding. The introduction of the internet and online information has had, and is having, a huge impact on information management. I have just read an article in CILIP’s lates Update on Out Sourcing (Library & Information Update July/August 2007 Vol 6 p 4)and maybe this is something the survey should consider covering too?

    Margaret Jones
    Lester Aldridge LLP

  3. James Mullan

    Margie I agree with your comments. Perhaps one of the areas the survey should look at is the challenges faced by Law Librarians and how we as professionals are dealing with these. I’m thinking of issues like Outsourcing, changing user demnands and technology. I’m sure there are lots more.

  4. James Mullan

    Margie I agree with your comments. Perhaps one of the areas the survey should look at is the challenges faced by Law Librarians and how we as professionals are dealing with these. I’m thinking of issues like Outsourcing, changing user demnands and technology. I’m sure there are lots more.

  5. Joy Branigan

    I think it should definitely be repeated. Anything that outlines the fact that law librarianship is a discrete sector of librarianship is good for our sector (even though I am not currently working for a law firm I still work for solicitors!).

    A couple of things I’d like to see it specifically cover:

    Knowledge management – with appendixes of the actual systems used – its always difficult to find market analysis of who is using what which is always a good place to start when thinking about buying a system.
    Commentary on how difficult it is to get people to buy in to these
    systems with solutions on how this can be achieved would also be good
    (will the research conduct interviews? I.e.. verbatim experiences are more interesting to read than ‘dry’ statistics).

    The same as above but on Library Management Systems.

    I think every five years is enough if it is going to be a large, wide
    ranging study.

  6. Joy Branigan

    I think it should definitely be repeated. Anything that outlines the fact that law librarianship is a discrete sector of librarianship is good for our sector (even though I am not currently working for a law firm I still work for solicitors!).

    A couple of things I’d like to see it specifically cover:

    Knowledge management – with appendixes of the actual systems used – its always difficult to find market analysis of who is using what which is always a good place to start when thinking about buying a system.
    Commentary on how difficult it is to get people to buy in to these
    systems with solutions on how this can be achieved would also be good
    (will the research conduct interviews? I.e.. verbatim experiences are more interesting to read than ‘dry’ statistics).

    The same as above but on Library Management Systems.

    I think every five years is enough if it is going to be a large, wide
    ranging study.

  7. Joy Branigan

    I think it should definitely be repeated. Anything that outlines the fact that law librarianship is a discrete sector of librarianship is good for our sector (even though I am not currently working for a law firm I still work for solicitors!).

    A couple of things I’d like to see it specifically cover:

    Knowledge management – with appendixes of the actual systems used – its always difficult to find market analysis of who is using what which is always a good place to start when thinking about buying a system.
    Commentary on how difficult it is to get people to buy in to these
    systems with solutions on how this can be achieved would also be good
    (will the research conduct interviews? I.e.. verbatim experiences are more interesting to read than ‘dry’ statistics).

    The same as above but on Library Management Systems.

    I think every five years is enough if it is going to be a large, wide
    ranging study.

  8. Jas

    I definitely think that this survey should be repeated. If we don’t have any other benchmarking for our special law library sector then this is important. I would have thought that every 5 years would be a good benchmakring – it’s not too frequent to be annoying, and it would show the change in technology and work methods well.

    Issues I would like to see covered would be:
    – technology – what technology are we using for research
    – training – how are professionals coming into the library professional – formal training etc
    – training our users – what are we using to train the users on the resources available -what are the main databases for legal research and how have they developed, and what are future developments
    – trends in research
    – knowledge management as a role of librarians
    – job titles
    as well as the items in the conclusion which should also be addressed so that some comparison of data can be made.

    I really feel that this is worthwhile project and I hope that the survey will be taken forward in some form or other.

    Jas Breslin | Information Services Co-ordinator Morrison & Foerster MNP

  9. Jas

    I definitely think that this survey should be repeated. If we don’t have any other benchmarking for our special law library sector then this is important. I would have thought that every 5 years would be a good benchmakring – it’s not too frequent to be annoying, and it would show the change in technology and work methods well.

    Issues I would like to see covered would be:
    – technology – what technology are we using for research
    – training – how are professionals coming into the library professional – formal training etc
    – training our users – what are we using to train the users on the resources available -what are the main databases for legal research and how have they developed, and what are future developments
    – trends in research
    – knowledge management as a role of librarians
    – job titles
    as well as the items in the conclusion which should also be addressed so that some comparison of data can be made.

    I really feel that this is worthwhile project and I hope that the survey will be taken forward in some form or other.

    Jas Breslin | Information Services Co-ordinator Morrison & Foerster MNP

  10. Loyita

    I thought that the Law and Order project was a good one and achieved two purposes.
    Firstly it gave us a snapshot of the profession as it was then and secondly gave BIALL some very much needed publicity.
    The publicity was to a large extent achieved by Sweet & Maxwell and it was obviously in their interest to do so given that they had sponsored it. I know that the PR and Promotions Committee are looking generally at raising BIALL’s profile but it would be difficult for the Committee to replicate the kind of coverage given by S&M.
    I think that it would be a good idea to revisit Law and Order given that someone could be found to sponsor it. It would be too big and too expensive for BIALL to tackle alone.
    If it were to be done on the same basis as last time i.e. an ‘in depth’ study, then I think that every 5 or 10 years would be ideal – annually or every 2 years would be too frequent.
    Just looking at the conclusions on the BIALL website things seem to have moved on a lot. Whilst the aim could be fundamentally the same, there are different issues within legal information which ccould merit possible exploration.
    As far as sponsors are concerned, Sponsiorship would have to be from a fairly significant stakeholder in the legal information field because of the cost involved and to enable them to benefit from their financial input.

  11. Loyita

    I thought that the Law and Order project was a good one and achieved two purposes.
    Firstly it gave us a snapshot of the profession as it was then and secondly gave BIALL some very much needed publicity.
    The publicity was to a large extent achieved by Sweet & Maxwell and it was obviously in their interest to do so given that they had sponsored it. I know that the PR and Promotions Committee are looking generally at raising BIALL’s profile but it would be difficult for the Committee to replicate the kind of coverage given by S&M.
    I think that it would be a good idea to revisit Law and Order given that someone could be found to sponsor it. It would be too big and too expensive for BIALL to tackle alone.
    If it were to be done on the same basis as last time i.e. an ‘in depth’ study, then I think that every 5 or 10 years would be ideal – annually or every 2 years would be too frequent.
    Just looking at the conclusions on the BIALL website things seem to have moved on a lot. Whilst the aim could be fundamentally the same, there are different issues within legal information which ccould merit possible exploration.
    As far as sponsors are concerned, Sponsiorship would have to be from a fairly significant stakeholder in the legal information field because of the cost involved and to enable them to benefit from their financial input.

  12. Loyita

    I thought that the Law and Order project was a good one and achieved two purposes.
    Firstly it gave us a snapshot of the profession as it was then and secondly gave BIALL some very much needed publicity.
    The publicity was to a large extent achieved by Sweet & Maxwell and it was obviously in their interest to do so given that they had sponsored it. I know that the PR and Promotions Committee are looking generally at raising BIALL’s profile but it would be difficult for the Committee to replicate the kind of coverage given by S&M.
    I think that it would be a good idea to revisit Law and Order given that someone could be found to sponsor it. It would be too big and too expensive for BIALL to tackle alone.
    If it were to be done on the same basis as last time i.e. an ‘in depth’ study, then I think that every 5 or 10 years would be ideal – annually or every 2 years would be too frequent.
    Just looking at the conclusions on the BIALL website things seem to have moved on a lot. Whilst the aim could be fundamentally the same, there are different issues within legal information which ccould merit possible exploration.
    As far as sponsors are concerned, Sponsiorship would have to be from a fairly significant stakeholder in the legal information field because of the cost involved and to enable them to benefit from their financial input.