Last day at AALL …

Today's presentations I attended included : Negotiation skills for librarians by Lorraine Busby; The future of Cataloguing by Michael Gorman and Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) in law libraries by Ann Puckett (and another speaker not listed in the programme). I noticed Fiona Durrant was at the first and the third too, so she may well blog about those two. For me the most provocative and stimulating presentation was Michael Gorman's.

Michael eloquently belittled the trend to de-structure the library catalogue and to replace it with free-text searching, folksonomies and meta-data. He argues that without a structured bibliographic record, subject indexing using controlled vocabularies, and related entries you would be creating a "hugely inefficient retrieval system". Thinking about it, I abhor the trend of library schools these days to make cat, class and subjecting indexing optional rather than core components of a library science qualification - it's what differentiates librarians from any other profession after all. I also think back to my own shock at joining my first law firm and finding that the depth of practice that I had learnt at library school and practised in academic libraries wasn't as appropriate in my law firm library and made no sense to the lawyers. So I adopted the shallowest level of AACR2 cataloguing rules and even ignored them when it came to the author. After all the lawyers would look up Woodfall on Landlord & Tenant under 'Woodfall' and not the actual author or editor writing under the shadow of the long dead and gone Woodfall. But I still maintained a structured and indexed catalogue and the happy compromise worked for both me and the lawyers. On the whole I agree with Michael that we are in danger of sliding into chaos resulting in poor retrieval if we don't apply consistent structures to our catalogues, databases or any other information storage mechanism and a retrieval tool that exploits that structure. However, I interpreted his stance as basically an anti Web 2.0 stance and surprisingly I found myself agreeing with him, but whilst preserving in my thought processes that I wouldn't dismiss web 2.0 - it certainly has its uses - I am blogging after all!

This is connected and a good example - have a look at the Google search I have put on the BIALL web site. See BIALL's welcome page
http://www.biall.org.uk/Home.asp?id=h1. The search works, it took 5 minutes to do and provides a facility we don't yet have on the BIALL web site, but it is far from perfect. The Google search is of course free-text so I am finding it yields too many results and in keeping with the inverse ratio of recall to relevance, too many irrelevant results. On the other hand it searches the full text of the PDF and Word documents in the site and I am impressed with the speed with which it does it. However there is no way restrict your search to the title, an index, an author, a page, a subject, a document type - it just searches everything. So there is absolutely no way to refine the search to narrow the results and even with our small content there are often too many results to plough through. It proves Michael's point precisely. To use his metaphor - it's the MacDonalds approach to information retrieval - the equivalent of fast food.

By the way if you do want to put a Google search on your own choice of web sites - click 'Custom Search' in the search results window and follow their instructions. It is how I did this one and it's easy. You can create a search over one web site or several. Have fun and let me know what you think of the Google search on the BIALL web site
.

You May Also Like...

BIALL Goes Mad in Dorset

If your favourite childhood reading included the Famous Five and/or pony books then pack your ginger beer and...

0 Comments