
Karen Palmer, president of the British & Irish Association of Law Librarians (BIALL) and senior information officer at Simmons & Simmons LLP, examines the challenges surrounding the use of web links by lawyers in this interview by Alex Heshmaty of LexisNexis. This article was first published on Lexis®PSL Dispute Resolution on 10 February 2015.
What are the challenges when using URL links as citations in court documents?
Ephemeral (or grey) literature is the technical term for 'information' not published commercially or indexed by major database vendors. 'Ephemeral' is also an excellent description for a URL citation.
The internet is not a permanent record, and web pages are not necessarily all that durable unless they are deliberately preserved. When the URL is created it will be unique to the resource that uses it. But the problem is that, although the information could be found at the time that URL link is made, this content might not still be at this address when the URL is used at a later point in time. URL links are not a 'solid' reference point to the information contained on the page that is displayed, just the 'location' of a page at a particular time.
However, if the URL is the only source for the information then you may have no choice but to cite using that URL. When citing a URL it is good practice to not only provide the URL, but to also note the date of access as the document or the website may be subject to change.
What effect might it have if the web address is changed (content drift) or the content is deleted (content rot)?
URLs/links are less likely to work as they get older--it has been estimated that the average life of a web page is just 100 days. Links may fail for a number of reasons:
- denial-of-service attacks
- censorship, or
- simple link rot
Dead links are a problem for Internet users everywhere. If you reference content from the internet, then you must remember there is no guarantee that the same content will be at that same URL later. If a document cites a URL, then by the time someone goes to access the link it is possible that the resource that was originally being referred to will have been amended, moved or deleted. Just because the URL still 'works', it does not mean that the content is still the same--documents can be changed or manipulated, and the information that will be retrieved at a later date may not be the same as was originally being referenced. If the content is no longer the same, then the point of including the link is lost.
Should lawyers be archiving their own relevant web content to ensure they can create permanent links to web content?
The answer to this is--it depends. Other questions to consider could be:
- How confident are you that in the future the content you need will continue to be available from the 'original' link?
- What would be the consequence if you could no longer access that information?
If web content is to be the subject of litigation, then it may be that the content should be archived before a claim is made. If pertinent web content is found at a later point in the proceedings, this content is not guaranteed to continue to exist, and it may be prudent to preserve it.
However, that still leaves the question as to whether it should be the lawyer archiving their own versions on their own systems. What is really needed is an authoritative source--if both sides claim that 'their' version is 'right', version wars could ensue.
A very recent entrant to the web archiving sector is the perma.cc service, and this could be that 'authoritative' source. The service has been developed by the Harvard Law School Library in conjunction with university law libraries, and website states that it is still in beta, but the service's stated aim is to let its users create citation links that will never break. Slightly worrying for a potential user of the service, the following is to be found in the terms and conditions:
'WE MAKE NO REPRESENTATIONS, WARRANTIES, OR UNDERTAKINGS AS TO PERMANENCE OR THE DURATION OF PRESERVATION...'I realise that this is standard legalese, but this doesn't fill me with confidence that this service is 'in the "forever" business' as they state on the website.
For personal research, an option is to use the archive.today service to save webpages. This service
describes itself as a 'personal Wayback Machine' but, as with any service, its continued existence is not guaranteed.
Can lawyers gain access to internet archives to assist in proper citation of historic web content?
If you want to cite historic web content, then accessing the 'old' websites will only be possible if they have been archived (and for that archive to be from a point in time that actually assists you). Two established services that researchers commonly might be using are the Wayback Machine (the Internet Archive) and the British Library archive project in the UK. It should be noted that not all websites and pages are included in these services. The Internet Archive honours the robots exclusion standard, and will not archive sites that disallow access (examples of such sites include the New York Times and The Washington Post).
If a lawyer is technically confident and competent then there is no reason why they could not access these services. However, if help is needed, then a friendly law librarian will have the necessary skills to help them, and we are always happy to assist with research of this nature.
These are not the only options available for accessing historic content. Another option is to use 'Time Travel'. Prior versions of web pages are named 'Mementos'. This service helps find versions of a page that existed at some time in the past from web archives, or in systems that support versioning such as wikis and revision control systems.
How have the courts and lawyers in other jurisdictions addressed these issues?
In the US the Legal Information Preservation Alliance (LIPA) was created following a conference in 2003 which was sponsored by the Georgetown University Law Library and the American Association of Law Libraries. Participants at the conference decided to establish LIPA as an organisation that would provide a framework for creating solutions to the problems of preserving legal information.
Last year 'link rot' was the topic of an article published in Legal Information Management, the journal of the British and Irish Association of Law Librarians by Jonathan Zittrain et al, Perma: Scoping and Addressing the Problem of Link and Reference Rot in Legal Citations (2014) 14 LIM 88. The article was originally published in the Harvard Law Review, and it cited alarming figures about the extent of the 'link rot' in legal documents in the US. Solutions suggested in this article included adopting digital object identifiers in citations, using the Internet Archive, and an archival/permalink approach which is already used in other professions such as medicine.
I am aware that the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, in San Francisco, has addressed the issue of preserving URLs that are cited in the court documents. It maintains an electronic archive of what it calls 'webcites' in PDF format.
0 Comments